In a recent ruling, the U.S. Tax Court concluded that transfers of LLC interests were in fact transfers of LLC interests. If this conclusion sounds obvious, it isn’t. In Pierre, the owner of certain assets formed a single member limited liability company, or LLC, contributed those assets to the company, then both gifted and sold portions of the company to trusts for her children – a fairly standard estate planning strategy.
When forming such an entity the IRS allows the selection of several different ways to be taxed. Among the options are for a LLC to be taxed as a corporation or as a “disregarded entity.” Here, the owner opted for the LLC to be taxed as a disregarded entity. That means that “for tax purposes” the entity is viewed not to exist and all tax aspects flow directly to the sole owner of the LLC. For ownership and liability purposes however, the entity very much exists. Under New York law (where the company was located) the owner of an LLC has no interest in the assets held by the LLC, she only had a personal property interest in the entity itself. It is these two conflicting legal concepts on which Pierre turned. The IRS argued, unsuccessfully, that a transfer of an interest in a disregarded entity was actually a transfer of the underlying asset(s) held by the LLC because “for tax purposes” the LLC doesn’t exit. Pierre argued that, under state law, she had no interest in the underlying asset to transfer, only LLC interests and therefore could not transfer the underlying asset(s). A rather divided tax court ultimately agreed with Pierre saying the entity selection rules, otherwise referred to as the “check-the-box” rules, that allow the entity to be “disregarded for tax purposes” did not apply to transfers of an interest in the company. Accordingly, a transfer of a LLC interest is a transfer of an interest in the entity and not a transfer of any specific asset owned by the entity.
There are two questions you should be asking yourself. First, what is the significance of this ruling? Well, if you gift a piece of real property worth one million dollars the gift tax would generally be based on the full one million dollar value. However, when the same asset is owned in a LLC and an interest in the LLC is gifted the tax code allows you to discount the value of the LLC interest transferred. So in this example you might get a 20% discount and only have to pay tax on $800,000 and not one million dollars (this is an oversimplified example). Second, does this ruling apply to Washington state LLC’s? The answer presumably is yes. Washington State’s limited liability company act contains a provision very similar to that of New York where the owner of the LLC has only an interest in the company and not in the assets owned by the company.